Easy Mixed Berry Icebox Cake

This post may contain affiliate sales links. Please read my disclosure policy.

This easy Mixed Berry Icebox Cake transforms six simple ingredients into a super refreshing no-bake dessert! Golden Oreo cookies are layered with juicy berries, cheesecake pudding and whipped cream! It’s delicious and perfect for summer!

The Best No Bake Berry Icebox Cake

I’m always looking for cool, easy treats to enjoy during the summertime – especially ones that don’t require any cooking or baking. This fruity icebox cake is one of my favorites! Fresh berries combine with sweet golden Oreo cookies and creamy cheesecake pudding in a simple, refreshing dessert that will have everyone coming back for seconds.

When I first created this masterpiece for Memorial Day some time ago, my relatives were skeptical. They weren’t familiar with icebox cakes and the combination seemed odd. However, the skeptics ended up becoming the cake’s biggest fans. They asked me for the recipe and have been making it themselves ever since! You truly have to try it!

What Is Icebox Cake?

Before electric refrigerators were a thing, people would chill their food in non-mechanical vessels known as iceboxes. When these containers were invented and mass-produced, Southern bakers began creating all sorts of treats that weren’t previously possible in warmer climates. Thus, the icebox cake was born.

Icebox cakes consist of three signature layers – wafer cookies, fresh fruit and a creamy filling. Even though iceboxes are a thing of the past, this classic dessert has maintained its popularity. And it’s easy to see why!

Ingredients and Substitutions

Before we dive into the step-by-step instructions, let’s go over our ingredients one by one. Scroll down to the recipe card for the full amounts.

• Cheesecake-Flavored Pudding: I personally love the flavor this adds, but if you are having trouble finding it, feel free to use vanilla pudding, white chocolate pudding or another flavor like lemon.
• Milk: I’d recommend 2% or whole milk. Most of this will be used to make the pudding, but you’ll need an extra half cup to dip the Oreos into to help them soften up.
• Golden Oreos: You could use regular Oreos, if you’d like a chocolate flair. I personally like the Golden Oreos because they don’t over power the berries.
• Strawberries: Rinsed, dried and sliced.
• Blueberries: Rinsed and dried.
• Whipped Cream: I used Homemade Whipped Cream, but you can also use Cool Whip.

How to Make Mixed Berry Icebox Cake

When I’m preparing this cake on a hot summer day, I’ll use the microwave to make my pudding so I don’t have to fuss with the stove. After that, the only appliance involved is the freezer.

• Make Pudding: Make both cheesecake-flavored puddings according to the package directions, using 4 cups of the milk (2 cups per package). Set the prepared pudding aside.
• Prepare First Oreo Layer: Pour the remaining half cup of milk into a small bowl. Give the Golden Oreos a quick dip into the milk, then place them into the bottom of a 9×13-inch pan, forming a single layer.
• Add Filling: Spread half of the cheesecake pudding on top of the Oreos.

• Add Strawberries: Add a single layer of strawberry slices on top of the cheesecake pudding.
• Top With Cool Whip: Spread half of the whipped cream/Cool Whip on top of the strawberries.

• Prepare Second Oreo Layer: Dip the remaining Oreos into the milk quickly, then place them on top of the Cool Whip in a single layer.
• Add Filling: Top the Oreo layer with the remaining cheesecake pudding.
• Add Blueberries: Add a layer of blueberries.
• Top With Cool Whip: Top the blueberry layer with the remaining whipped cream/Cool Whip.
• Add Berries: Arrange the remaining blueberries and strawberry slices on top of the cake in any pattern of your choice.
• Chill: Refrigerate the cake overnight or for at least 3-4 hours. Once it has fully chilled, cut it into slices and enjoy!

Tips for Success

Take a second to review these tips before you start making your icebox cake.

• Use Fresh Fruit: Frozen fruit tends to be a little soft, mushy or soggy once thawed. Definitely stick with fresh fruit for this dessert.
• Dip the Oreos Quickly: Only dip the Oreos into the milk for a moment. If they soak up too much liquid, they’ll become soggy rather than soft.
• Chill for 2 Hours Minimum: The filling of this icebox cake doesn’t really need to firm up, but the Oreos do need a little time to soften and become easier to slice and eat. I’d recommend at least 2 hours. Three hours would be even better.

Storage Instructions

Keep this cake in an airtight container in the fridge for up to 2-3 days. The fruit in the icebox cake will begin to release their juices over time, so the sooner you serve and eat it, the better.

More Great Icebox Cakes

• Strawberry Shortcake Icebox Cake
• Raspberry Almond Icebox Cake
• Banana Pudding Icebox Cake
• Reese’s Peanut Butter Icebox Cake
• Cannoli Icebox Cake
• Mint Oreo Icebox Cake

Watch The Video

Read Transcript

Print